Why It’s Better To Have Your Mitral Valve Repaired than Replaced

Having your mitral valve repaired before symptoms become severe can increase your longevity. Here’s one patient’s story.

5:00 AM

Author | Jane Racey Gleeson

gif of a healthy heart pumping and a mitral valve regurgitation
Michigan Medicine

When Thomas Kimble discovered he would need to have his mitral valve repaired, he was happy to get a recommendation from his Florida cardiologist for a surgeon highly skilled in minimally invasive procedures.

This eased the decision for the Florida resident to move forward, even though, like many individuals, he wasn't experiencing symptoms of his mitral valve regurgitation, which may include fatigue, shortness of breath, chest pain and an irregular heartbeat.

In fact, just prior to his November 2020 surgery with Michigan Medicine Frankel Cardiovascular Center surgeon Gorav Ailawadi, M.D., the 68-year-old was hiking at 11,000 feet in Breckinridge, Colorado. "I may have felt a little fatigued, but I attributed it to my age," he says.

How the mitral valve works

The body's mitral valve controls the flow of blood from the lungs through the pulmonary veins to the heart and eventually to the body. If its flaps (or leaflets) don't close properly or don't open completely, the heart has to work harder, which can lead to atrial fibrillation, blood clots, stroke and congestive heart failure.

For patients like Kimble with mitral valve regurgitation, the flaps of the valve fail to close completely, causing blood to travel backward into the left atrium of the heart. Without treatment, the heart muscle can become weak or damaged.

A telltale sign

An incidental diagnosis of a heart murmur is often the telltale sign of mitral valve disease, says Ailawadi. This is why regular checkups are critical.

"Having a valve repaired at a center of excellence before symptoms worsen is a smart decision for many patients and can increase life expectancy," he says. "There are often subtle changes in the size of the heart that signal it is working overtime even before there are symptoms. Whenever possible, it's better to repair the mitral valve rather than replace it."

MORE FROM MICHIGAN: Sign up for our weekly newsletter

Mitral valve repair may help you to avoid complications that can occur with mitral valve replacement, including the risk of blood clots with mechanical valves. For this reason, patients who undergo a replacement procedure need to be on blood-thinners for the rest of their lives. They may also face the risk of a biological tissue valve failing over time.

Being in good physical condition when undergoing a mitral valve repair procedure is also beneficial in several ways, including:

  • Reduced risk of complications after surgery

  • Quicker recovery

  • Better preservation of heart function

  • Reduced risk of stroke

  • Reduced risk of atrial fibrillation

A trend toward less invasive procedures

"We can repair mitral valves using different treatment methods, including open-heart, minimally invasive and transcatheter procedures," says Ailawadi, noting that more and more minimally invasive and transcatheter procedures are being performed at Michigan Medicine over open-heart surgeries.

A minimally invasive mitral valve procedure involves small incisions between the ribs on a patient's right side to access and repair or replace the valve.

In a transcatheter procedure, the heart valve is accessed via a catheter through a patient's blood vessel, typically the femoral vein.

Kimble was happy to know he would avoid the need for open-heart surgery.

Like Podcasts? Add the Michigan Medicine News Break on iTunes or anywhere you listen to podcasts.

"The patient had severe mitral regurgitation and his heart was starting to dilate," says Ailawadi, but his valve and chordae, which had ruptured, could be repaired without the need to open his breastbone. Chordae are thin, cordlike tendons that support the mitral valve leaflets as they open and close. When they become stretched or broken, as in Kimble's case, the valve cannot close properly.

A positive experience and outcome

Though drawn from his home in Florida by the reputation of Ailawadi as an expert in minimally invasive surgery, Kimble was equally impressed by what he describes as a "superb" program at the Frankel Cardiovascular Center.

In support of this, Michigan Medicine was one of the first five centers in the country to be designated as a Mitral Valve Repair Reference Center by the American Heart Association and the Mitral Foundation. This designation is awarded to hospitals that have shown excellence in clinical outcomes and performance in mitral valve repairs.

"From pre-op testing to surgery, everything was superb, even during COVID," Kimble says. "Everything was highly organized, which added to my confidence."

Kimble spent five days in the hospital after surgery, with light activity restrictions for four weeks afterward. 

Today, nearly five months since his surgery, Kimble is eager to get back to the gym for weight lifting and spinning classes.

"I want to get ready for a more active summer and spending time with our four grandkids."

Kimble and his wife, Janet, are thankful for an early intervention that allowed the repair versus replacement of his mitral valve.

"The entire experience has been fantastic," he says. "My valve was repaired and I was pleased with how it went. I highly recommend Michigan Medicine and Dr. Ailawadi. I'm grateful for his skill set. I'm referring people already."

More Articles About: Heart Health Valve Disease Valve Repair and Replacement Cardiovascular: Diseases & Conditions
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories Women cheers with champagne glass
Health Lab
Octogenarian Finds Hope with MitraClip Procedure
Local woman, whose mitral valve disease was worsening, plans her 90th birthday celebration thanks to a minimally invasive option.
watch on hand
Health Lab
Tailored text messages not enough to improve mobility after heart issues
A Michigan Medicine report shows that adding a mobile health application to such devices yields mixed results. Tailored text messages to encourage high-risk people to move more may improve some short-term outcomes but doesn’t always improve physical activity levels for everyone.
man smiling sitting
Health Lab
A unique collaboration helps one patient better manage aortic disease
MI-AORTA is a donor-funded initiative that facilitates collaboration within the Frankel Cardiovascular Center, U-M Health and referring provider networks, creating value for the patients, families, and communities they serve and allows them to continue to pioneer advanced therapies for aortic diseases.
man standing
Health Lab
Beating the odds against chronic total occlusion
Learn about the latest advances in treatment for chronic total occlusion, a life-threatening condition that deprives the heart of oxygen. A team of cardiovascular surgeons perform advanced, minimally invasive surgery to help David Schneider get his life back on track.
Health Lab
Pulmonary embolism deaths, disparities high despite advancements in care
Despite these innovations, a Michigan Medicine study finds that the death rate for pulmonary embolism remains high and unchanged in recent years – more often killing men, Black patients and those from rural areas. The results are published in the Annals of the American Thoracic Society.
hospital staff emergency room patient rush
Health Lab
Nearly three-quarters of stroke patients requiring higher level of care wait over two hours for transfer
More than 70% of people experiencing a stroke who require a transfer wait longer than two hours to be transferred from the initial emergency department to hospitals with higher levels of care to receive time-sensitive care, a study finds.