Whole-body MRIs aren't as beneficial as they seem

Knowing every abnormality in your body is tempting, but experts say ignorance may be bliss

5:00 AM

Author | Valerie Goodwin

MRI scan drawing
Justine Ross Michigan Medicine

In recent news, Kim Kardashian made an Instagram post about a whole-body MRI scan she received and the benefits she saw from it, encouraging her followers to do the same.

While a whole-body MRI scan seems like a great preventative health tool from the outside, it might do more harm than good.

Scans, like the one Kardashian had are meant to find any cancers, aneurysms or other harmful anomalies within the body before they become something untreatable and/or life threatening.

While it’s tempting to know what's going on inside your entire body, a recent clinical perspective piece written by Matthew Davenport, M.D., a radiologist at the University of Michigan, discusses some of the harms of imaging low risk patients, such as overdiagnosis, overtreatment and their related complications.

Less is more

According to Davenport, approximately 15% to 30% of all diagnostic imaging in adult patients contain at least one incidental finding.

These are small abnormalities in the body that are doing no harm and wouldn’t have been located unless a scan was performed of that area.

“Incidental findings happen in any type of MRI or CT scan, typically while conducting a scan to find something else,” said Davenport. “New whole-body MRI scans are scans that seek out incidental findings, which make the results seem more alarming than they are.”

Patients that receive incidental findings from scans are at an increased risk of experiencing overtreatment, creating the illusion of benefits while, instead, causing harm to themselves.

Screenings, such as these, are more likely to identify indolent disease, one that grows slowly or not at all, than an aggressive type.

Although it can cause panic and a feeling of urgency to treat, addressing it can actually cause more harm than good.

“Most incidental findings don’t need to be treated, and aren’t serious. However, attempting to maximally diagnose [patients] causes significant costs and time, results in additional testing and procedures, and their related complications, and can result in emotional and physical harm," said Davenport.

"It makes healthy people think of themselves as patients," he noted.

Most patients will feel physically better if they leave their indolent diseases or incidental findings alone, Davenport says. For many, knowing every abnormality in your body can increase anxiety and change how you view your personal health, causing negative mental side effects.

“If you went into the scan feeling normal and came out seeing all your incidental findings as problems, it is going to change how you feel about your health,” said Davenport. “Now, your view of your quality of life has changed to something negative when that might not be the case. This can be very stressful and anxiety inducing for many patients.”

The allure of a whole-body MRI is the possibility that the scan locates a cancerous mass in the body before it would have started causing the patient symptoms or harm, resulting in early and potentially life saving treatment.  But, according to Davenport, this is very unlikely to happen in healthy, asymptomatic patients without significant risk factors.

“There is a reason that there is no cancer society, radiology society, or credited medical society that recommends whole-body MRI screening in asymptomatic healthy patients without risk factors,” said Davenport.

“It is not a safe and effective way to detect potential ailments early in the average healthy person.”

Proper screenings

Most radiologists would not recommend patients have a whole-body MRI, unless there's a medical history that proves otherwise.

“Imaging is appropriate for patients who have a genetic risk of life-threatening cancer or have a sign or symptom of significant disease,” said Davenport. “Balancing risks and benefits is best suited through a conversation between a patient and their health care provider.”

When it comes to the general population, Davenport says ignorance is bliss.

“Many patients will have indeterminate findings within their bodies that will appear on a whole-body MRI,” Davenport said.

“Typically, they aren’t cause for concern, but the uncertainty induced by identifying them often results in extensive diagnostic workups with little benefit and the potential for harm. For majority of patients, the harms of this approach outweigh the benefits.”

If you have concerns about an illness based on family history or are concerned about an incidental finding on a scan, it's important to have a conversation with your primary care physician before starting any treatment.

Authors on this paper include Matthew S. Davenport, Department of Radiology and Department of Urology at the University of Michigan Health System

Study cited: “Incidental findings and low-value care,” American Journal of Roentgenology. DOI: 10.2214/AJR.22.28926


More Articles About: Cancer Diagnosis Cancer Screening Cancer Testing Tumors and Lumps Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) Health Screenings Community Health Future Think All Research Topics Hospitals & Centers
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe
Featured News & Stories Illustration of hand holding list, with pill bottle in opposite and and small pic of doctor talking to patient
Health Lab
New urine-based test detects high grade prostate cancer, helping men avoid unnecessary biopsies
A new urine-based test addresses a major problem in prostate cancer: how to separate the slow growing form of the disease unlikely to cause harm from more aggressive cancer that needs immediate treatment.
Photo of a cluttered, messy garage
Health Lab
Chemicals stored in home garages linked to ALS risk
A Michigan Medicine study finds that storing chemicals in a garage at home may associate with an increased risk of ALS.
Blue image of a microscopic helix strand
Health Lab
Researchers discover urine based test to detect head and neck cancer
At-home test can detect tumor DNA fragments in urine samples, providing a non-invasive alternative to traditional blood-based biomarker tests
Health Lab
How to protect your eyes during the total solar eclipse
A Michigan Medicine ophthalmologist and retinal surgeon shares advice for viewing the total solar eclipse safely, including what to look for in eye protection.
heart organ yellow blue
Health Lab
Around 10% of deaths from coronary stenting, balloon angioplasty are preventable
Around 10% of all deaths following percutaneous coronary intervention are potentially preventable, a study led by Michigan Medicine finds.
Photo of two silhouettes in a hallway
Health Lab
Most new doctors face some form of sexual harassment, even after #MeToo
Sexual harassment of all kinds is a common experience among first-year medical residents, also known as interns, especially those in surgical specialties, but it may be declining.