How to Choose a Child Care Provider: 6 Tips from a Pediatrician

A new C.S. Mott poll reflects the challenges parents face in finding child care or preschool. Here’s how to make the search easier and more effective.

7:00 AM

Author | Kevin Joy

For parents of many newborns, choosing child care can be a daunting task.

Beyond costs and logistics, there's a lot families must factor into the decision.

MORE FROM MICHIGAN: Sign up for our weekly newsletter

"It's a tough challenge," says Andrew Hashikawa, M.D., an assistant professor of pediatric emergency medicine at the University of Michigan C.S. Mott Children's Hospital. "And it's more than a 'drop-off' location: Child care is an opportunity for children to develop, grow, learn and be ready for kindergarten."

The latest C.S. Mott Children's Hospital National Poll on Children's Health focused on these issues, identifying what matters most to parents selecting child care. The survey involved 2,051 parents with children ages 1 to 5 who attend a day care or preschool.

Building security, staff training and availability of educational and active play were among the top priorities.

Still, of those polled, nearly two-thirds cite difficulty finding child care with the characteristics they want. Only half are confident they could tell if a facility or provider is safe and healthy.

Hashikawa, who sits on the American Academy of Pediatrics Council on Early Childhood and focuses on early childhood education, offers his advice:

Tips for finding child care

Start early: Some families might not begin their search until a baby is born. That's often too late: "As soon as you're thinking about having a baby, you need to start the process," Hashikawa says. "A lot of the good child care centers have waitlists." That head start allows parents enough time to arrange visits and research a variety of options.

Check credentials: Although regulations and compliance vary by state, a licensed provider offers peace of mind that background checks and educational training are verified. "It really gives that stamp of approval," says Hashikawa. He suggests parents visit Child Care Aware for advice — and, to compare researched and rated options in Michigan, Great Start to Quality.

SEE ALSO: Kid with a Chronic Illness? 5 Tips for Parent-Teacher Teamwork

Make a surprise visit: An impromptu drop-in shows what the facility is like on a given day. Notes Hashikawa: "Look around to see how providers engage children — are they interacting and allowing them to play with toys, or are they sitting in front of a television?" Check, too, for cleanliness and a low adult-to-child ratio (1:4 for infants and 1:10 for older kids).

Study the curriculum: Brains of babies and young children develop rapidly from birth to age 5. "Health and nutrition and learning and stimulation are really important during that time," Hashikawa says. Ask about educational toys, open play, lesson plans and activities, outdoor space and mealtime structure. Accredited facilities should have these details readily available.

Know the vaccine policy: Although inoculations can be a contentious issue, most child care centers "are very pro-vaccine," Hashikawa says. "It helps protect staff, it helps prevent kids from getting sick more often and it protects vulnerable infants." Forty-one percent of Mott poll respondents would avoid care providers that allow unvaccinated children to attend.

Stress safety: More than half of those surveyed say a gun on the premises would be a deal breaker. That's unlikely in a child care center or preschool, but it's possible at an unlicensed at-home provider. Notes Hashikawa: "Parents should ask: Are there weapons on the premises? Are they locked up? Who else is coming and going?" Research crime rates of the area, too.

More Articles About: Children's Health CS Mott Children's Hospital Hospitals & Centers
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories pregnant stomach with yellow dots and blue undertone lab note
Health Lab
Few pregnant people who died of overdose, suicide in Michigan received proper treatment before death
A review of maternal deaths suggests most individuals had documented behavioral health conditions but only one-third received appropriate pharmacologic treatment before death
child looking at family outside of kitchen area
Health Lab
Encouraging spirituality in teens without forcing participation
Among parents who plan to attend religious services this holiday season, nearly half would insist their teen join even if they didn’t want to, a poll suggests.
Health Lab
Social media: Top setting tips to promote positive boundaries, mental health for young people
Experts share tech savvy ways to better manage and control social media use on Instagram, TikTok and YouTube for youth, teens and kids.
child cough sick parent with temp check
Health Lab
RSV: What parents should know
How you can prevent infection and look for more serious symptoms of RSV.
Mom and patient with doctor viewing brain waves
Health Lab
How deep brain stimulation helped a 10-year-old from having multiple seizures a day
DBS treatment has more commonly been used in adults with epilepsy but is now helping children like Rylan improve their quality of life. 
school traffic safety kid car orange
Health Lab
Parents worry school traffic is a danger for kids
Speeding and distracted drivers top list of concerns; some say those who don’t follow rules should face consequences.