Disparities in accessing care could worsen if audio visits aren’t available as a telehealth option

Audio-only appointments represented almost half of telehealth visits in the study.

12:17 PM

Author | Mary Clare Fischer

laptop stethoscope pen lab notes
Jacob Dwyer, Justine Ross, Michigan Medicine

Audio-only appointments made up nearly half of the Department of Urology's telehealth visits during the first few months of the pandemic, research found.

Forty-four percent of patients who had a telehealth visit for a urological concern from April 1, 2020, to June 30, 2020, used audio but not video functions. 

Factors that affected whether patients preferred audio over video or did not have the technological capacity for video calls included:

  • Older age

  • Black or American Indian/Alaska Native ethnicity

  • The need for an interpreter

  • Living in a rural area or a region with limited broadband Internet access

  • Having Medicaid health insurance

"Our findings suggest that audio encounters may be an important medium for certain patient populations to connect with their physicians during the COVID-19 public health emergency and beyond," said Chad Ellimoottil, M.D., an assistant professor of urology at the University of Michigan Medical School and telehealth expert who was the senior author of the study.

Ellimoottil notes that the start of the pandemic was an ideal time to study patients' telehealth preferences because in-person appointments were so limited at the time.

"Patients needed to select a video visit or phone visit," said Ellimoottil, who is also a member of the University of Michigan Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation. "Those that chose a phone call likely did so because they did not have the capability to perform a video visit."

Right now, Medicare and many other insurers reimburse audio visits at the same rate as video visits, but providers have been concerned that audio-only visits will not be a long-term option in the United States. 

So far, equal Medicare reimbursement for audio and video visits has been tied to the public health emergency, which President Biden recently extended until October 13. As of July 29, though, the U.S. Senate is considering a bill that would extend audio-only coverage until the end of 2024. Even then, it's possible that some insurers could require a video component for a provider to bill an interaction with a patient as a visit.

"Reimbursing only video-based telehealth could potentially contributor to or further exacerbate disparities in urological access to care and health," Ellimoottil said. "Extending reimbursement for audio-based telehealth can help mitigate this issue by making remote care available to all populations."

Other authors include Erica Jaiyeola Odukoya of the University of Michigan Medical School; Juan Andino of the U-M Department of Urology and IHPI; and Sophia Ng and Emma Steppe of IHPI.

Ellimoottil is a member of the Urology Practice editorial committee and was recused from the editorial and peer review processes for this paper.

Paper cited: "Predictors of Video versus Audio-Only Telehealth Use among Urological Patients," Urology Practice. DOI: 10.1097/UPJ.0000000000000301

More Articles About: Lab Notes Urology Health Care Delivery, Policy and Economics Emerging Technologies
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of health care news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories screen of chart and xray and patient and doctor white coat vague in background at computer sitting at keyboard
Health Lab
Pre-op visits by video? Most surgeons say no – but open to post-op telehealth
A survey of surgeons shows most aren’t in favor of operating on a patient they’ve never seen in person, but many are open to telehealth appointments after a successful operation.
person holding arm with band aid teal shirt
Health Lab
More hospitals than ever require staff to get flu shots
Flu vaccination mandates for hospital staff have increased in recent years, especially at hospitals serving veterans
older woman in red long sleeve shirt waving from open door of blue house with other woman leaving with long silver hair and checkered shirt with white undershirt turned towards the door
Health Lab
Most older adults don’t know about resources for navigating aging and caregiving
Social and health services aimed at older adults have low awareness rates among people over 50, suggesting more effort is needed to spread the word to patients and caregivers.
woman putting something in vial in lab coat and purple gloves, glasses and mask in clinical looking area
Health Lab
Altering cancer treatment dosing could reduce climate impact, study finds
Changing how often a popular cancer therapy is delivered would reduce greenhouse gas emissions and improve environmental impact without decreasing cancer survival, according to a new analysis from researchers at the University of Michigan Health Rogel Cancer Center.
weight scale black white in exam room close up
Health Lab
Adding obesity experts to primary care clinics improves patients’ weight loss outcomes
A weight navigation program for primary care patients with obesity led to more use of proven weight management strategies and more weight loss
zoom screens with 7 different backgrounds and doctor silhouettes outlined in each
Health Lab
The doctor is in…. but what’s behind them?
A study reveals that what a doctor has behind them during a telehealth visit can make a difference in how the patient feels about them and their care.