Which Self-Help Websites Actually Improve Health? New Research Yields a List

Plenty of websites promise to help people with health issues — but many lack gold-standard testing or public access. Research highlights the right resources for those in need.

9:00 AM

Author | Kara Gavin

The internet teems with self-help sites that promise to help people improve their health. But which of these outlets have been evaluated through gold-standard studies and have evidence to support their claims?

MORE FROM MICHIGAN: Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

A new paper compiles only the best of the best: a list of more than 40 sites backed by evidence from randomized controlled trials.

Compiled by a team at the University of Michigan Medical School, the list includes sites that offer people help with reducing their use of alcohol, tobacco and marijuana; managing mental health issues; and improving diet and physical activity. Other topics include insomnia, chronic pain, cardiovascular risk and childhood health issues.

Published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, the list highlights sites that go beyond educational information to help people understand, and approach, a condition.

The web-based programs typically are structured like courses, with stepwise, interactive modules based on psychological principles and offline assignments. Some programs take weeks or months to complete. Several sites are free to the general public; others charge a fee.  

"This list is just a start," says Mary Rogers, Ph.D., a research associate professor at U-M and a member of the U-M Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation. "New trials are completed on an ongoing basis, so we suspect that there will be additional websites with effective interventions added to this list over time. It is important that procedures are in place so that people know where to find health information that is backed up by science."

Still, the search can be challenging: Rogers and her colleagues found that nearly 80 percent of effective online approaches to health-related self-help, shown to work in randomized controlled trials, aren't currently available or have since been taken down.  

The researchers hope that their work will help not only the general public in search of answers but also clinicians who want to steer their patients toward evidence-based online tools to help them between clinic visits.

If there is an internet program that can help someone improve their health and there's little extra cost involved in maintaining it, we should provide more avenues to keep these sites available.
Mary Rogers, Ph.D.

About the study

The investigators started by doing a massive search for research papers in any language, and from any health field, that compiled the evidence from randomized controlled trials for online self-help approaches. They found 71 such papers, called meta-analyses, which looked at the results from 1,733 studies.

SEE ALSO: Can a Website Keep Suicidal Thoughts Away?

But through this review, the researchers found that only 21 percent of the online programs had a functioning website after the study was finished.

Rogers and her colleagues note that the end of a grant to support a trial of an online program also often signals the end of a research team's efforts to provide it. After the trial, then, ongoing support for web hosting and technical upgrades may not be available. The authors call for efforts to continue hosting such sites after the trials are completed.

Many of the websites provide precautionary information to seek professional medical attention for health questions. Some sites also provide resources for health professionals.

For example, painACTION, which was created using funds from the National Institutes of Health, offers resources for both patients and physicians to help patients manage chronic pain. For every four people with chronic back pain who used the online program, one person experienced improvement compared with a control group. For every three people with migraines who used the site, one person experienced improvement compared with a control.

Although the sites on their list have evidence behind them, this does not guarantee a benefit for every individual who uses a given site, Rogers and her colleagues note. Compared with people who don't use the site, though, they do offer a greater likelihood of a benefit if the program is completed.

Most of the effective online health programs are available in English. But some are available in Spanish, French, Portuguese, Dutch, German, Norwegian, Finnish, Swedish or Mandarin Chinese. 

With 3.5 billion internet users worldwide, future research is necessary to determine whether online programs work equally well for people with different social and cultural backgrounds.

Also necessary is a shared effort to keep the information live and accessible.

Notes Rogers: "If there is an internet program that can help someone improve their health and there's little extra cost involved in maintaining it, we should provide more avenues to keep these sites available. It could represent potentially great cost effectiveness globally. In addition, we have to do a better job of letting people know that there are evidence-based sites to help them."

Website locations for the effective self-help programs are listed online (PDF).

In addition to Rogers, the research team includes Kelsey Lemmen, Rachel Kramer, Jason Mann and Vineet Chopra, M.D.

More Articles About: Rounds Wellness and Prevention Smoking Cessation Mental Health Smoking and Vaping
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories patient giving paperwork and person saying no with hand graphic moving teal white grey navy orange
Health Lab
Why new patient paperwork isn’t just busy work
While it’s easy to overlook doctor's office questionnaires, that paperwork actually serves a vital role in better understanding how to treat you. Called patient reported outcomes, this information gives medical specialists insight into how treatments truly impact you as a patient.
A family discussing their family's medical history at Thanksgiving
Health Lab
Why you need to discuss your family health history at Thanksgiving
The holidays are a great time to discuss your family's medical history. Learn the importance of discussing your family's health history & how to bring it up.
physician talking to patient with lab researcher in background
Health Lab
Older adults left out of clinical research trials
Including older adults in research can be beneficial, explains a Michigan Medicine research, who says more should, and can be, done to have their insights.
older woman on phone with credit card in hand
Health Lab
Health plays a role in older adults' vulnerability to scams
Most older adults have faced an attempted scam, and some have been defrauded, but rates were higher among those with health problems or disabilities.
Chlld holding vape container parent coming into room
Health Lab
E-cigarette exposure on the rise in young children: 6 things parents should know
Pediatrician: Just a few drops of liquid nicotine can be lethal in a toddler
people holding band-aid umbrella standing in the rain
Health Lab
5 things to know about health insurance right now
Open enrollment season for Medicare, Healthcare.gov Obamacare plans, work-related insurance is here – and Medicaid enrollment renewal is due for many. How to get help.