Study: Health Plan Deductibles Hit Patients with Chronic Illness Harder

As a new health insurance year begins and a health policy debate swirls, research examines what people with chronic illnesses spend on health care.

11:00 AM

Author | Kara Gavin

Patients discussing their high deductible health plan costs

For tens of millions of Americans, the start of a new year means the counter has gone back to zero on their health insurance deductibles. If they need health care, they'll pay for some of it out of their own pockets before their insurance takes over.

MORE FROM THE LAB: Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

As insurance plans with deductibles grow in popularity, a new study takes a national look at what those plans mean for people with common chronic health conditions such as diabetes, asthma, joint problems and heart disease.

The short answer: a hit to their wallets.

Those with chronic conditions who choose deductible-based plans should be prepared to spend hundreds or even thousands of dollars of their own money on their care — beyond what they spend to buy the insurance plan in the first place.

The results, reported in JAMA Internal Medicine by researchers from the VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, the University of Michigan Medical School and Penn State University, especially show the impact of high-deductible health plans. Such plans now cover 40 percent of Americans who buy their own health insurance or get it through an employer.

Using data from a national survey of Americans younger than 65, the researchers found that having a high-deductible plan makes it more likely that health-related costs will take up more than 10 percent of a chronically ill person's total income.

Researchers uncovered wide disparities in out-of-pocket spending among patients with the same condition, even for those in low-deductible plans.

Despite these out-of-pocket costs, the study found that few people with chronic illnesses said costs or insurance coverage issues had gotten in the way of getting the care or prescriptions they needed.

"Increasingly, these plans have become woven into the fabric of health insurance in America, so it's important to look at the impact of deductibles on people who need care on an ongoing basis," says senior author Jeffrey Kullgren, M.D., M.S., M.P.H., "not only on how they spend their money on care for their day-in, day-out health needs, but also how that affects spending in the rest of their lives."

Kullgren is a research scientist in the VA Center for Clinical Management Research of the VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System and an assistant professor of general medicine at the U-M Medical School.

Increasingly, these plans have become woven into the fabric of health insurance in America, so it's important to look at the impact of deductibles on people who need care on an ongoing basis.
Jeffrey Kullgren, M.D., M.S., M.P.H.

Surveying patient experience 

Kullgren and first author Joel E. Segel, Ph.D., a Penn State health economist, analyzed data from 17,177 people interviewed for the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey, a nationally representative survey conducted by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. The data were collected from 2011 to 2013, when many more employers started offering high-deductible health plans.

SEE ALSO: Medicaid Expansion More Than Pays for Itself, Study Finds                                                                           

Of all the respondents, slightly more than 4,100 had a high-deductible health plan, and more than 7,600 had a chronic health condition. About 45 percent of those with high-deductible plans had at least one chronic condition.

Researchers looked at data from people who had heart disease, high blood pressure, diabetes, asthma, joint diseases, cancer (except for skin cancer) and mood disorders such as depression. They compared those patients' out-of-pocket costs against those of individuals with none of these conditions. The data encompassed those who had plans with high deductibles, low deductibles and no deductibles.

In 2013, a plan was considered high deductible if it asked patients to pay the first $1,250 in care costs for an individual or $2,500 for a family. Only people with deductibles above this amount qualify to open a health savings account that lets them put away cash to use tax-free to pay for some health costs.

Changes to the insurance market

The data primarily come from the time before people who needed to buy their own insurance could do so on the marketplace. Since the launch of the marketplace, more than 90 percent of shoppers have chosen high-deductible plans.

Lower-income people who choose silver-level marketplace plans can get assistance with out-of-pocket costs from the federal government. But those who opt for bronze-level plans with high deductibles — but lower monthly premium costs — aren't eligible for deductible help. Neither are people who make more than the income limit or receive coverage outside of the marketplace.

"If changes in health policy remove marketplace subsidies, that could rewind the clock to the era we studied," says Kullgren. 

A basis for future work

Kullgren, a member of the U-M Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation and the Center for Bioethics and Social Sciences in Medicine, specializes in studying the impact of consumer-directed health care plans — a phrase that encompasses those with high deductibles or other cost-sharing arrangements.

SEE ALSO: Even with Insurance, Hospital Patients May Pay Over $1,000 Per Stay

He also studies how the companies that run such plans, or offer them to their employees, can help participants understand the costs and medical choices they will be responsible for.

"A lot of plans, employers and policymakers are using these plans as vehicles to make consumers more active in their care, more cost-conscious and more interested in optimizing the value of their care," Kullgren says. "This includes offering price-transparency tools that people can use to see what the care they need will cost and quality tools to show which hospitals or providers offer the best value.

"But we don't know yet how often people are using these tools to help them get the care they need and avoid the care they don't need, nor how well the tools serve their needs," he adds. "We need to focus on helping people who are in these plans use them better."

Kullgren is analyzing national survey data from people enrolled in high-deductible health plans who were asked about these topics. He is also partnering with Priority Health, a major private insurer, to design a pilot project that will launch early this year. It will test a price-transparency tool that patients and health providers can use together, during a clinical appointment, to make decisions based on medical need and cost.

"One challenge of high-deductible health plans is that clinical decisions made in a doctor's office are often completely disconnected from the reality of what a patient has to pay out of pocket," he says. "Patients have to decide whether and where to get a service, such as an operation, lab test or medical imaging exam, that they must pay for under their plan. These are decisions where clinicians can help patients navigate — and in some cases help them avoid care they don't need."

More Articles About: Industry DX Health Care Delivery, Policy and Economics Diabetes Cardiovascular: Diseases & Conditions Bones and Muscles and Joints (Orthopaedics)
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories Adult performs CPR on a young athlete, illustration with red and blue figures
Health Lab
Sudden cardiac arrest in young athletes: 5 things parents should know
Sudden cardiac arrest in young athletes: 5 things parents should know
Illustration of girl with blue water line, depicting a figure drowning, as girl contemplates pill in hand
Health Lab
Antidepressant dispensing to adolescents and young adults surges during pandemic
Rate of antidepressant dispensing to young people rose faster after March 2020, especially among females
Scale pictured behind a hospital room curtain
Health Lab
Obesity care can make a big difference, but few get it, study suggests
Obesity care under a health care provider’s supervision, whether through nutrition counseling, medication, meal replacement or bariatric surgery, can help people with high BMI, but many don’t receive it.
Provider takes a pulse oximetry reading from a patient's finger
Health Lab
Inaccurate pulse oximeter readings could limit transplants, heart pumps for Black patients with heart failure
Racially biased readings of oxygen levels in the blood using pulse oximeters may further limit opportunities for Black patients with heart failure to receive potentially lifesaving treatments, such as heart pumps and transplants
Woman in pink shirt lifts kettleball in an outdoor exercise class
Health Lab
How to make cancer prevention more equitable
Expert explains six behavioral risk factors for cancer and why current programs don’t always meet the needs of people from racially and ethnically minoritized groups and other vulnerable populations.
Graphic with diabetes management supplies, a clipboard that reads health insurance, a calculator and money
Health Lab
High out-of-pocket costs hindering treatment of diabetes
According to a Michigan Medicine study, people with diabetes, particularly those with type 1 diabetes, endure substantial out-of-pocket expenses compared to people without diabetes.