One-Third of Breast Cancer Patients Consult PCPs About Treatment Options

A new study calls attention to the need for better partnerships between primary care physicians and oncologists.

7:00 AM

Author | Nicole Fawcett

Oncologist and primary care physician working together on cancer treatment

As more people survive cancer, primary care physicians and oncologists must work together to manage patient care. That's because once cancer treatment ends, patients eventually transition back to their primary care physician.

SEE ALSO: Breast Cancer Patients Who Use Social Media More Satisfied with Treatment Decisions

But a new study finds this alliance may need to start even sooner. Researchers found more than a third of women newly diagnosed with breast cancer consulted with their primary care physician about cancer treatment options.

Although that's a good sign for collaborative care, it also raises some concerns, says study author Lauren Wallner, Ph.D., MPH, assistant professor of general medicine at the University of Michigan Medical School.

"If primary care physicians are involved in cancer treatment decisions, we need to make sure they have the resources they need to properly counsel patients faced with these complicated decisions. Previous studies have shown that primary care doctors say they do not always have the information they need to participate in team-based care," Wallner says.

The study, published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, surveyed 2,272 women about six months after a breast cancer diagnosis. Nearly two-thirds of women rated their primary care as high quality and felt their physician was engaged in their care. Nearly 70 percent perceived high communication with their primary care physician about their cancer care. For 35 percent, the primary care physician participated in the treatment decision.

Black, Hispanic and Asian women reported more involvement from primary care physicians than white women. In addition, women with less education and women with multiple other health problems were more likely to consult their primary care doctors.

"Primary care physicians were more likely to be engaged in populations that are at risk of poorer outcomes. This is a crucial opportunity to engage in collaborative care," Wallner says.

The better informed primary care physicians are ... the better [the] transition will be once cancer treatment ends.
Lauren Wallner, Ph.D., MPH

The role of PCPs in cancer care

Primary care physicians often have longer relationships with their patients than oncologists, and may be more attuned to a patient's values, preferences and needs. In the study, researchers found that most patients had been seeing their primary care doctor for two years or more.

SEE ALSO: For Breast Cancer, When Does Worry Outweigh Risk?

Collaborative care is particularly important when patients have multiple health conditions. A primary care physician can help better manage other conditions, as well as preventive care, during cancer treatment.

One caveat to the researchers' findings, however, is that patients who reported their primary care physician was more involved in their cancer treatment did not express more satisfaction with the treatment process or their treatment decision. Wallner suggests more research is needed to better understand the content of these treatment decision conversations and how to integrate primary care into cancer treatment.

Wallner recently received a grant to develop a navigation tool focused on fostering team-based care for breast cancer patients. Identifying opportunities to improve communication between oncology and primary care will be a key feature of this work.

"Primary care physicians are already participating in cancer care before diagnosis, during treatment and into survivorship. It's essential to make sure communication channels are open during that whole process. The better informed primary care physicians are — involved during the continuum of cancer care and not just after the fact — the better that transition will be once cancer treatment ends," Wallner says.

More Articles About: Industry DX Breast cancer Cancer: Cancer Types
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories Radiation therapy of young women breast cancer
Health Lab
Physicians Don’t Always Recognize Patients’ Radiation Therapy Side Effects
A new study finds that significant side effects were under-recognized in both younger patients and Black patients being treated for breast cancer.
Breast cancer graphics
Health Lab
How Hereditary Genetic Testing Results Impact Breast Cancer Treatment
Breast cancer patients who test positive for an inherited genetic mutation, such as having the BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene, may be receiving treatment based on future cancer risk, rather than guideline approved treatments for their diagnosed cancers, study finds.
Doctor with patient
Health Lab
Some Primary Care Doctors Not Prepared to Help with Cancer Treatment Decisions
Up to 1/3 of primary care providers discussed breast cancer treatment options with patients but many report gaps in their knowledge.
Health Lab
‘When Are We Going to Cure Cancer?’: The Bright Future of Breast Cancer Research
When will we cure breast cancer? See how breast cancer treatment has evolved since 1960 and find out what the future of breast cancer treatment and research holds.
Health Lab
Some Breast Cancer Patients Don’t Need Radiation. Why Are They Still Getting It?
Read the findings from a new study examining overtreatment of breast cancer, specifically why many women receive radiation therapy they may not actually need.
A patient considering a contralateral prophylactic mastectomy
Health Lab
Study Finds ‘Striking’ Use of Double Mastectomy
One in six early stage breast cancer patients choose double mastectomy. Learn about unnecessary bilateral mastectomy and why patients choose to have it.