Mitral Valve Repair vs. Replacement: Why Early Intervention Matters

Millions of patients have mitral valve surgery each year. How one Michigan Medicine patient decided which option was best for her.

7:00 AM

Author | Jane Racey Gleeson

The onset of mitral valve disease didn't keep Perry Katsikas from living an active life. Relatively free of symptoms, she continued to exercise daily.

MORE FROM MICHIGAN: Sign up for our weekly newsletter

But Katsikas, like many of the millions of Americans diagnosed with a degenerative version of the disease, faced a decision: Should she have her mitral valve repaired or wait until her condition required complete valve replacement?

The body's mitral valve controls the flow of blood in one direction from the lungs to the body. If the valve doesn't close properly or open completely, the heart may have to work twice as hard to do its job which can lead to atrial fibrillation, embolism, blood clots, stroke and congestive heart failure.

Under the care and counsel of Francis Pagani, M.D., a cardiac surgeon at the University of Michigan Frankel Cardiovascular Center, Katsikas chose repair.

Today, the Ann Arbor, Michigan, resident praises the decision: "Early intervention saved the quality of my life."

Weighing mitral valve repair vs. replacement

The Frankel Cardiovascular Center is home to one of the largest mitral valve practices in the country. Heart surgeon Steven Bolling, M.D., conducts hundreds of mitral valve repairs there each year.

Bolling says repair is "always better than replacement."

SEE ALSO: Does an Enlarged Aorta Always Mean Surgery?

The reason? "The heart's power is derived from the mitral valve," he says. So if a patient waits for symptoms to warrant replacement, it means the heart has already been compromised.

Valve repair, Bolling tells his patients, "will put you back on your natural life survival rate," as if a heart issue had never occurred.

A typical patient with mitral valve disease has been under a doctor's care for a long time, Pagani says. Indications of the need for mitral valve repair include a murmur that has gotten louder or regurgitation (backward blood flow) that has worsened.

Advantages of mitral valve repair

Katsikas' recovery was typical of many patients. She spent five days in the hospital after surgery in 2010, with light activity restrictions for three or four weeks afterward.

It helps for patients to be in good health when having mitral valve repair, Pagani and Bolling note. That can ensure the following benefits:

  • Reduced risk of complications after surgery

  • Quicker recovery

  • Better preservation of heart function

  • Reduced risk of stroke

  • Reduced risk of atrial fibrillation

Now 69 years old and still active, Katsikas can't imagine making a different decision or going anywhere else for treatment.

"I came in feeling healthy, had surgery and went home feeling healthier," she says. "I felt Dr. Pagani cared about me and my outcome. And the outcome speaks for itself."

Learn more about treatment options for mitral valve disease offered at U-M's Frankel Cardiovascular Center. To make an appointment or discuss a need for treatment, call 888-287-1082.

More Articles About: Heart Health Valve Repair and Replacement Valve Disease Frankel Cardiovascular Center Cardiovascular: Treatment & Surgery
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories doctor checking heart on patient
Health Lab
Leading experts release new guidelines to improve congenital heart surgery care for children
For the first time in more than 20 years, dozens of pediatric cardiologists, surgeons and other health professionals have come together to develop new guidelines intended to improve heart surgery care for this population of children and teens.
man standing
Health Lab
Beating the odds against chronic total occlusion
Learn about the latest advances in treatment for chronic total occlusion, a life-threatening condition that deprives the heart of oxygen. A team of cardiovascular surgeons perform advanced, minimally invasive surgery to help David Schneider get his life back on track.
hospital staff emergency room patient rush
Health Lab
Nearly three-quarters of stroke patients requiring higher level of care wait over two hours for transfer
More than 70% of people experiencing a stroke who require a transfer wait longer than two hours to be transferred from the initial emergency department to hospitals with higher levels of care to receive time-sensitive care, a study finds.
person walking on treadmill
Health Lab
Cardiac rehabilitation reduces risk of death years after heart surgery, still underutilized
A Michigan Medicine study finds people who participate in cardiac rehabilitation have a decreased risk of death years after surgery, with a trend towards better outcomes in patients who attend more sessions.
Doctors Surgeons Heart Surgery Operation
Health Lab
Researchers discover new opportunities for preventing kidney injury following cardiac surgery
Researchers discover new opportunities for preventing kidney injury following cardiac surgery.
family standing together selfie
Health Lab
Paying it forward
A patient with severe aortic stenosis receives a specialized surgery to save his life at Michigan Medicine.