Medicare prior authorization affecting plastic and reconstructive surgery didn’t have hoped-for effect

A new policy increased wait time for patients, but didn’t speed up the move from hospital-based to outpatient-based operations

2:42 PM

Author | Valerie Goodwin

medical files medical health insurance paper someone picking it up
Getty Images

A policy aiming to save Medicare money has not had the intended effect on outpatient surgery. 

As the policy expands across the country, researching the results of this policy could inform how adjustments are made moving forward.

The Medicare policy change added something that’s common in private insurance and Medicare Advantage, but rare in traditional fee-for-service Medicare: requiring doctors to get prior authorization from Medicare officials before scheduling certain outpatient procedures. 

Aimed at saving money, the policy sought to make sure certain procedures done at hospitals were medically necessary and not just cosmetic, such as blepharoplasties (eye lid surgery), abdominoplasties (“tummy tucks”), botulinum toxin injections (Botox injections), rhinoplasties (procedures to change the shape of the nose) and vein ablations (removal of visible veins).

The policy, CMS-1717-FC from the federal government, requires that patients with Medicare receive prior authorization to undergo these surgical procedures at hospital outpatient surgery departments. 

At the time the policy went into effect in 2020 it did not apply to ambulatory surgery-based care where patients may also undergo these same-day surgery procedures. 

A new policy is now extending the prior authorization requirement to ambulatory surgery centers starting in certain states.

But at the time of the study, patients covered by traditional Medicare could have the same procedures without prior authorization at ambulatory surgery centers, which are often less costly for same day surgery than hospital outpatient departments. 

However, such centers are still bound by Medicare policy that does not allow these procedures to be covered if they are not medically necessary; billing Medicare for a purely cosmetic procedure is considered fraud. 

Leading a research team at University of Michigan Medical School, Joseph N. Fahmy, M.D., M.S, a research fellow at University of Michigan Health working with Kevin Chung, M.D., a professor of plastic surgery, aimed to evaluate if this policy was effective at reducing hospital outpatient department based surgical volume.

The results showed that there were no significant changes in hospital outpatient department surgical volume after the policy went into effect. 

There had already been a shift away from such centers before the policy, but it did not accelerate after the policy.

Despite the intention to decrease surgical volume and shift surgical care from more expensive hospital outpatient departments to ambulatory surgical centers, the authors conclude that the policy was ineffective in speeding up the process of achieving this goal. 

Fahmy notes that prior authorization in general causes a disruption in administrative workload as well as in the timeliness of care.

“Our findings suggest that the administrative workload increased without the intended impact of reducing the volume of patients having these surgeries at hospital outpatient departments,” said Fahmy.

“For patients, this means that the policy will result in their team having to do extra paperwork which has the potential to delay their care. This makes it important for administrative teams to be aware of the increase in workload as well as patients to be aware that there is potential for a delay in receiving care.”

Fahmy and his team see this as a sign that changes need to be made to shift the flow of surgical patients without putting a strain on administrative teams that may already be feeling pressure.

“Colleagues in our field should advocate for other policy levers to constrain spending, such as narrowing payment disparities between different facilities performing the same surgery,” said Fahmy.

“The data suggest that alternative policy levers to prior authorization are better suited to accomplish goals of reducing spending on surgical care nationally without increasing administrative workload. These policy approaches may include narrowing payment gaps between hospital outpatient departments and ambulatory surgery centers for similar care.”

Additional authors: Trista M. Benítez, M.P.H. from the Section of Plastic Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, MI; and Zhongzhe Ouyang, M.S. and  Lu Wang, Ph.D. from the Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan School of Public Health, Ann Arbor, MI.

Funding/disclosures: Plastic Surgery Foundation Pilot Grant, National Institutes of Health T32 training grant (5T32GM008616-23), American Foundation for Surgery of the Hand.

Tech transfer(s)/Conflict(s) of interest: Joseph Fahmy has potential conflicts including support from grants from the national institutes of health, Plastic Surgery Foundation, and American Foundation for Surgery of the Hand 

Paper cited: “2020 CMS prior authorization for hospital outpatient departments: Associated surgical volume impact,” Surgery. DOI: 10.1016/j.surg.2024.07.010 

Sign up for Health Lab newsletters today. Get medical tips from top experts and learn about new scientific discoveries every week. 

Sign up for the Health Lab Podcast. Add us wherever you listen to your favorite shows.  


More Articles About:

Social Status All Research Topics Health Care Delivery, Policy and Economics Surgery Pre- and Post-Operative
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells

Health Lab

Explore thousands of health news & research stories by visiting the Health Lab homepage for more.

Media Contact

University Hospital at U-M Health in the spring with flowering trees in foreground and Survival Flight helicopter visible

Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

In This Story

Kevin Chung

Kevin C Chung, MD, MS

Professor

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe

Featured News & Stories

Alarm clock sitting on a white dinner plate with blue and yellow flowers on the rim and a fork and knife positioned on either side of the plate.
Health Lab

Intermittent fasting can reverse diabetes in mice, study finds

Study shows intermittent fasting and meal timing can help reverse type 2 diabetes by resting pancreatic beta cells
Close up of woman's mouth as cheek swab is performed, with Q tip held in a green medical gloved hand.
Health Lab

Are you at risk of a genetic disease? Guidelines for testing should be updated, experts say

Genetic counselor calls for updated guidelines on testing for diseases like Huntington's and Alzheimer's diseases.
Well-Being at Michigan Medicine with Dr. Elizabeth Harry
Well-Being at Michigan Medicine

Small Pauses, Bigger Impact: Mindfulness in Action

What if well-being was built into the places where we live, learn and work? In this episode, Dr. Elizabeth Harry, is joined by three guests: recent past AMA president Dr. Bobby Mukkamala, who is board-certified in otolaryngology (head & neck surgery); Lauren Holaly-Zembo, CEO of the Crim Fitness Foundation; and Dr. Lisa Sancrant, Assistant Vice Chancellor for Health and Well-Being at UM-Flint, about how Flint, Michigan, is making mindfulness a community-wide priority. From classrooms to workplaces, they explore how small, accessible practices can support mental health, reduce stress, strengthen organizational cultures and help create healthier, more compassionate communities.
Mother sits on a couch with a laptop on her lap while an elementary school age boy sits next to her playing on a tablet device.
Health Lab

New questionnaire aims to improve understanding of demand avoidance in children, teens

Pathological demand avoidance is a pattern of intense distress and avoidance of demands in children. A new questionnaire from University of Michigan researchers creates a structured way to assess these behaviors.
Blue round cells in three pictures showing how they change under stress.
Health Lab

Timing is of the essence for RNA during stress

Key determiners of which RNA can be read to make proteins is time. Previous thinking was that a cell under threat would quickly make these RNAs in the nucleus and immediately push them into the cytoplasm.
Blue and yellow illustration of DNA helix
Health Lab

New anti-cancer strategy shows promise in preclinical studies

New cancer therapeutic strategy rewires protein interactions to improve efficacy and reduce potential side effects.