Does Bariatric Surgery Help or Harm Patients with ESKD?

A new study assesses the impact of bariatric surgery on patients with end stage kidney disease.

11:56 AM

Author | Jina Sawani

See through body of end stage kidney disease with teal blue background
Image created by Stephanie King.

The kidneys act as a filtration hub in the human body, filtering waste and removing excess water in the form of urine. Nearly 750,000 people in the United States have end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), which means that they have progressed to the final stage of chronic kidney disease and now require dialysis to stay alive.

Unfortunately, up to 40% of patients with ESKD also struggle with obesity, which reduces access to receiving a life-saving kidney transplant.

For patients without ESKD, bariatric surgery is the safest and most effective therapy for obesity. Yet while the health benefits associated with bariatric surgery are plentiful, the uptake of this weight-loss surgery in the ESKD population has been slow, with very few patients ever having the surgery.

"Two main issues traditionally prevent patients with ESKD from getting bariatric surgery," says Kyle Sheetz, M.D., a clinical four resident in general surgery at Michigan Medicine. "First, many perceive it to be unsafe, or that patients may have complications or even die after surgery. Second, data often shows that patients with obesity and ESKD actually have better long-term survival rates than non-obese patients with the same condition. This is referred to as the obesity paradox."

These notions inspired Sheetz and Seth Waits, M.D., a Michigan Medicine assistant professor of surgery, to find out if bariatric surgery improves the long-term survival rates for patients with both ESKD and obesity. Their findings were recently featured in JAMA Surgery.

"We wanted to shine a light on the potential benefits of bariatric surgery in a particularly vulnerable population," says Waits. "When you consider the reduction in cardiovascular morbidity and the increased likelihood of receiving a kidney transplant without obesity as a factor, a reduction in barriers to bariatric surgery can potentially be met with huge gains in patient care."

Sheetz further adds that previous research has shown that weight-loss surgery is safe for both patients with ESKD and without.

Outcomes and implications

Nearly 40% of patients on dialysis are obese and can potentially qualify for bariatric surgery.

The research team knew that they wanted to assess whether weight-loss surgery, something clinicians know carries massive health benefits to patients without ESKD, is associated with the same health benefits for patients on dialysis.

Therefore, they needed a large study pool.

We wanted to shine a light on the potential benefits of bariatric surgery in a particularly vulnerable population.
Seth Waits, M.D.

"We used a national registry maintained by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in order to capture a large number of patients around the country," says Sheetz. "While some prior work on this subject exists, we quickly realized that it is confined to small single-center studies that lack generalizability."

Once they analyzed their data, the team found that bariatric surgery was associated with better long-term survival rates when compared to matched controls receiving regular care. In addition, Waits notes that they found that bariatric surgery was linked to a higher incidence of receiving a kidney transplant.  

"While recent policy efforts, such as the Executive Order on Advancing American Kidney Health, focus primarily on improving the lives of patients with ESKD through improved dialysis and kidney transplant efforts, they often fall flat," says Waits. "Without an aggressive approach, the 40% of patients with ESKD and obesity suffer from limited access to receiving a kidney transplant and fewer favorable outcomes than patients without obesity. This is why our findings were so significant."

Sheetz goes on to add that they also found that the impact of bariatric surgery on long-term survival rates was independent of receiving a transplant.

"When combined with our previous research, our findings suggest that bariatric surgery is not only safe in patients with ESKD, but also associated with significant long-term health benefits," says Sheetz. "And this study was eye-opening because it showed us that we should be working towards a greater adoption of bariatric surgery for this vulnerable patient population." 

Paper cited: "Bariatric Surgery and Long-term Survival in Patients with Obesity and End-stage Kidney Disease," JAMA Surgery. DOI: 10.1001/jamasurg.2020.0829

More Articles About: Body Work Chronic kidney disease (CKD) Cardiovascular: Treatment & Surgery Weight Management Weight Management Surgical Surgery Types Bariatric Counseling Kidney Disease
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories Dinero is back to being an active toddler following a kidney transplant
Health Lab
Formula prescription helps 2-year-old receive kidney transplant
Dinero's pediatric nephrology team developed a tailored formula to address his mineral deficiencies due to his chronic kidney disease, maintain nutritional health and avoid dialysis.
heart organ yellow blue
Health Lab
Around 10% of deaths from coronary stenting, balloon angioplasty are preventable
Around 10% of all deaths following percutaneous coronary intervention are potentially preventable, a study led by Michigan Medicine finds.
Health Lab
Father’s cancerous brain tumor found weeks after the birth of his daughter
Father’s cancerous brain tumor found weeks after the birth of his daughter
Microscopic image of bone marrow with pink and white hues
Health Lab
Novel risk score for cardiovascular complications after bone marrow transplant
More bone marrow transplants, also known as hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, are being offered to older patients, a population at greater risk of cardiovascular disease.
Provider takes a pulse oximetry reading from a patient's finger
Health Lab
Inaccurate pulse oximeter readings could limit transplants, heart pumps for Black patients with heart failure
Racially biased readings of oxygen levels in the blood using pulse oximeters may further limit opportunities for Black patients with heart failure to receive potentially lifesaving treatments, such as heart pumps and transplants
News Release
Statewide cardiovascular consortium, hosted at Michigan Medicine, receives national award for patient safety, quality efforts
A collaborative partnership dedicated to improving statewide cardiovascular care and outcomes — hosted at Michigan Medicine — received national recognition for efforts in patient safety and quality. BMC2 received the award for its significant improvements in the documentation of radiation use, a decrease in high-dose radiation exposure and reduction in opioid prescribing rates for patients.