Cataract surgery reimbursements may not be enough for some patients

Medicare reimbursements for complex cataract surgery are far lower than a simpler form of the surgery

5:00 AM

Author | Tessa Roy

eye drawing
Jacob Dwyer, Justine Ross, Michigan Medicine

Research suggests that Medicare reimbursements for complex cataract surgery cover less than two minutes of operating time, and an increase to reimbursements for the procedure may be justified. Complex cataract surgery requires more time and resources than simple cataract surgery, and this study indicates that the incremental reimbursement for the complex surgery is not enough to offset the increased costs.   

“After accounting for the increased supply and material costs ($158.26), the remaining incremental reimbursement is $72.75, even without accounting for the additional postoperative visit associated with complex cataract surgery,” wrote David Portney, M.D. “With the per-minute operative costs of the surgeon, anesthesiologist, and operating room ($43.96/min), the incremental payment compensates for less than 2 minutes of operating time, a number far lower than the required time difference.” 

The research authored by Portney and interim chair Shahzad Mian, M.D., analyzed the difference in day-of-surgery costs and net earnings between simple and complex cataract surgery. The measured costs to providers for complex cataract surgery are significantly higher than simple cataract surgery, accounting for a difference of $877.85. This difference far exceeds the $231.01 incremental reimbursement provided by Medicare, leading to a net “negative” margin for complex cataract surgery. 

“This difference can impact ophthalmologist practice patterns and access to care for patients needing surgical care," said Mian. “These findings suggest ophthalmologists are disincentivized from taking more complex cases and patients, leaving academic and referral centers to cover the cost of the surgeries.”   

Accessibility issues for patients who require more complex surgery are also likely to emerge. 

“The downstream effect of this observation has significant implications for ophthalmologists, health care systems, and patients and may particularly affect the most vulnerable patients, including racial and ethnic minority individuals, who more commonly undergo complex cataract surgery,” Portney wrote. 

The study received no external funding and was performed as part of quality assessments initiatives at University of Michigan. 

Portney reported being the founder and owner of The Lens Newsletter. The study received no external funding and was performed as part of quality assessments initiatives at University of Michigan. 

Paper cited: “Comparison of Incremental Costs and Medicare Reimbursement for Simple vs Complex Cataract Surgery Using Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing,” JAMA Ophthalmology. DOI: 10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2023.0091


More Articles About:

All Research Topics Basic Science and Laboratory Research Kellogg Eye Center Hospitals & Centers Eye Care & Vision
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells

Health Lab

Explore thousands of health news & research stories by visiting the Health Lab homepage for more.

Media Contact

University Hospital at U-M Health in the spring with flowering trees in foreground and Survival Flight helicopter visible

Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe

Featured News & Stories

Mother sits on a couch with a laptop on her lap while an elementary school age boy sits next to her playing on a tablet device.
Health Lab

New questionnaire aims to improve understanding of demand avoidance in children, teens

Pathological demand avoidance is a pattern of intense distress and avoidance of demands in children. A new questionnaire from University of Michigan researchers creates a structured way to assess these behaviors.
Blue round cells in three pictures showing how they change under stress.
Health Lab

Timing is of the essence for RNA during stress

Key determiners of which RNA can be read to make proteins is time. Previous thinking was that a cell under threat would quickly make these RNAs in the nucleus and immediately push them into the cytoplasm.
Blue and yellow illustration of DNA helix
Health Lab

New anti-cancer strategy shows promise in preclinical studies

New cancer therapeutic strategy rewires protein interactions to improve efficacy and reduce potential side effects.
Closeup of newborn baby, whose head is held by a blue medical gloved hand. Blue gloved hand also holds a stethoscope to baby's chest.
Health Lab

More babies with hypoplastic left heart syndrome surviving critical period between surgeries

Collaborative effort helped sustain improvements in survival for babies born with hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS), a serious congenital heart condition that requires multiple surgeries.
Rachel Upjohn Building groundbreaking ceremony
News Release

How U-M helped bring depression out of the darkness

The history of the founding of the Eisenberg Family Depression Center at the University of Michigan, the nation's first center focused on research, community outreach and stigma reduction in depression and bipolar disorder.
1906 psychopathic hospital
News Release

Exploring the mind’s mysteries: 130 years of mental health care & innovation at U-M

When it opened in 1906 on Catherine Street near the University of Michigan’s main hospitals, the stately brick State Psychopathic Hospital meant something new in the world of mental health.