Carrots Plus Sticks: What Works to Reduce Low Value Care

Unnecessary vitamin D testing dropped dramatically in Canada after payment stopped, but Choosing Wisely guidelines also had an impact in both U.S. and Canada.

5:00 AM

Author | Kara Gavin

2020 Vitamind

The old story of a farmer trying to get a stubborn mule to pull a wagon by dangling a carrot in front of its nose, or hitting its rump with a stick, may not seem to have much to do with the practice of medicine.

But a new study suggests that when it comes to making the best use of health care dollars, it will take a combination of carrots and sticks to move things forward.

The study looks at the effects of two initiatives that aimed to reduce the use of two blood tests that experts consider "low value" for most patients: routine vitamin D tests and an unnecessary thyroid test for tracking thyroid hormone levels.

After an organization that advises the health care system in Ontario, Canada reported in 2010 that population-based vitamin D screening doesn't improve outcomes, the province's health plan for all residents declared it wouldn't pay for low value vitamin D tests.

MORE FROM THE LAB: Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

Soon after, the rate of testing dropped nearly 93%, the study shows. Patients who had a condition or medication that might lower their vitamin D levels could still get tested.

But in the United States, where no such payment change took place, 2.6 million unnecessary vitamin D screening tests happened in just one year, according to the researchers from the University of Michigan, University of Toronto and VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System who published the new findings in JAMA Internal Medicine.

SEE ALSO: Efforts to Improve Health Care Value Should Focus on Doing the Right Thing

A few years later, as part of an education campaign called Choosing Wisely, physician professional societies issued recommendations on when not to use vitamin D and T3 testing.  And while use of the test in Ontario dropped an additional 4.5%, the use in U.S. patients covered by Veterans Health benefits or commercial insurance dropped about 14%.

"Our study found small reductions in the use of unnecessary vitamin D screenings in response to recommendations from the Choosing Wisely campaign, but much greater reductions in Ontario when recommendations were complemented by policy change," says Eve Kerr, M.D., M.P.H., senior author of the new paper and a professor in the U-M Department of Internal Medicine.

"The biggest lesson is that while recommendations alone can work to reduce low value care, recommendations have greater impact when they are reinforced by changes to policy and practice."

Improving value

Kerr heads a program at the U-M Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation called the Michigan Program on Value Enhancement. She and her colleagues used the same Choosing Wisely guideline to build an alert for clinicians who had ordered a vitamin D test of low potential value into the electronic health record at Michigan Medicine, U-M's academic medical center.

Like Podcasts? Add the Michigan Medicine News Break to your Alexa-enabled device or subscribe for updates on iTunesGoogle Play and Stitcher.

In 2018, they reported that this guideline based "carrot" had led to a positive and sustained change in orders for low-value vitamin D tests.

James Henderson, Ph.D., the first author of the new paper, assistant director of MPrOVE and a data science consultant at U-M's Consulting for Statistics, Computing and Analytics Research unit, notes that the new paper's findings show that Choosing Wisely recommendations for T3 testing didn't appear to have had the desired impact.

While recommendations alone can work to reduce low value care, recommendations have greater impact when they are reinforced by changes to policy and practice.
Eve Kerr, M.D., M.P.H.

T3 testing, which is no longer recommended for patients with known thyroid issues because of a test called TSH that's more accurate, didn't decline in either the U.S. or Canada after Choosing Wisely guidelines were issued. In fact, in the study population of U.S. patients with private insurance, the rate of testing actually went up slightly.

Handle with care

Kerr, Henderson and their colleagues from IHPI and the VA Center for Clinical Management Research note that policy decisions for low value care – including payment changes – must be made with care, to avoid problems with access to that type of care for patients who could benefit.

For instance, the Ontario payment change exempted patients who have bone or digestive disorders that can change vitamin D levels, and patients who take certain medications that can change vitamin D absorption from food and supplements.

SEE ALSO: Researchers: 'Choosing Wisely' Off to a Strong Start, but It's Time to Evolve

"Payment policies are not the only effective means for reducing low-value care," says Kerr. "Indeed, sometimes restricting payment may be too blunt an approach and could lead to underuse."

She adds, "Other effective policies that can be coupled with recommendations include population based education programs, communication approaches to help patients and physicians make more patient-centered decisions, decision support for doctors about low-value care, and most importantly, culture change initiatives that emphasize the responsibility of health care institutions, clinicians, and patients to provide and seek high value, evidence based care while avoiding low value services."

Paper cited: "Comparison of Payment Changes and Choosing Wisely Recommendations for Use of Low-Value Laboratory Tests in the United States and Canada," JAMA Internal Medicine. DOI: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2019.7143

More Articles About: Industry DX Health Care Delivery, Policy and Economics Blood Work Lab Tests
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories
Health Lab
To Improve Global Health, a Standard List of Essential Diagnostic Tests
University of Michigan doctors create list of essential medical tests aligning with WHO's essential medicines. Learn more about the medical diagnostic tests.
Illustration of girl with blue water line, depicting a figure drowning, as girl contemplates pill in hand
Health Lab
Antidepressant dispensing to adolescents and young adults surges during pandemic
Rate of antidepressant dispensing to young people rose faster after March 2020, especially among females
Scale pictured behind a hospital room curtain
Health Lab
Obesity care can make a big difference, but few get it, study suggests
Obesity care under a health care provider’s supervision, whether through nutrition counseling, medication, meal replacement or bariatric surgery, can help people with high BMI, but many don’t receive it.
Woman in pink shirt lifts kettleball in an outdoor exercise class
Health Lab
How to make cancer prevention more equitable
Expert explains six behavioral risk factors for cancer and why current programs don’t always meet the needs of people from racially and ethnically minoritized groups and other vulnerable populations.
Dark staircase leading to blue sky above
Health Lab
Ketamine’s promise for severe depression grows, but major questions remain
New findings about the impact of IV ketamine on treatment resistant depression add more fuel to the potential for broader use and insurance coverage.
A dentist operates on a patient at Exalta Health in Grand Rapids
Health Lab
Using telehealth to serve disparate populations
A collaboration between Exalta Health and University of Michigan Health-West is a creative method of bridging language, financial, and technology gaps between patients and health care providers.