The Best OTC Meds and Supplements to Treat Headache

A headache expert explains what to take to ease the pain — as well as when to enlist help from a health care provider.

1:00 PM

Author | Cathy Mellett

One headache can ruin your day. Frequent or severe headaches can be a never-ending nightmare. Whichever headache type you have, you might be wondering how best to treat your symptoms.

SEE ALSO: Which OTC Pain Medication Works for What?

Below, neurologist and headache specialist Lauren A. Aymen, D.O., explains the best over-the-counter drugs and herbal supplements for headache, guidelines for use and when to seek medical care. 

Which over-the-counter (OTC) medications do you recommend for headache?

Aymen: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications (NSAIDs) are more powerful compared to acetaminophen because NSAIDs reduce inflammation. Examples of NSAIDs include Motrin, Aleve or Advil. I tend to prefer Aleve (Naproxen).

Do you recommend a certain strength?

Aymen: In terms of over-the-counter medications, strength is somewhat less important. I usually recommend that patients take the maximum dose as directed on the bottle. More importantly, the medication should be taken early once the headache begins.

How much over-the-counter medicine is too much?

Aymen: I tell patients they should avoid taking over-the-counter medications more than two to three times per week. Frequent use may cause side effects or even lead to medication-overuse headaches. If a patient requires an over-the-counter medication more than a few times per week, he or she should be seen by a physician. There are prescription medications that can be taken daily to reduce the frequency and severity of one's headaches.  

Are there nonprescription drugs or herbal supplements to take to avoid the possible side effects of over-the-counter medications?

Aymen: For patients experiencing headache at least 15 days per month, I recommend a trial of magnesium. There is some evidence that patients with migraine may have lower levels of magnesium within their brain. Measurement of magnesium in someone's blood does not accurately correlate with magnesium levels in the brain. Magnesium comes in several formulations, and I prefer magnesium oxide or magnesium glycinate. The only side effect to look out for is loose stool or diarrhea.  

SEE ALSO: Opioids: When the Harms Outweigh the Benefits

Other frequently used supplements for headache prevention include riboflavin (vitamin B-2), Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) and omega-3 fatty acids. It's important to always let your physician know about any supplements you are taking.

When should someone seek medical care?

Aymen: When OTC medications or supplements are ineffective and/or headaches are impacting a person's ability to perform activities of daily living, he or she should seek treatment from a physician.

More Articles About: Health Management Headache Neurological (Brain) Conditions
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]


Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Featured News & Stories
Health Lab
Migraine Nightmare Sparks Successful Photography Career
A seven-year stay in Ann Arbor inspired a migraine patient to become a professional photographer. Learn more about his art and new outlook on life.
A graphic showing headache causes and migraine remedies
Health Lab
When Should You See a Doctor for Headache or Migraines?
A U-M neurologist discusses migraines vs headaches and when to see a doctor for headaches. Learn what causes headaches and the best migraine headache relief.
Woman with headache symptoms during pregnancy
Health Lab
Pregnancy and Headache: Why It Happens and What to Do
Headaches during pregnancy are usually no cause for concern. Here's how to get pregnancy headache relief and when to see a doctor about your pregnancy migraine.
Animated microscopic image of the glioblastoma's tumor microenvironment
Health Lab
New model of key brain tumor feature could help scientists understand how to develop new treatments
Model shows how oncostreams form and behave in brain tumors – and how to inhibit them
Woman sweating hot flash fan
Health Lab
Menopause and migraines: New findings point to power of prevention
Women who have both migraines and a long-term history of hot flashes and/or night sweats have a slightly higher risk of heart disease and stroke, and young women who have migraines have a higher risk of later persistent menopause symptoms.
Patient lies in hospital bed after surgery with bandage on head, displays toys later after recovery
Health Lab
Lifechanging results for young woman after orange-sized brain tumor removed
Young woman thrives after surgery to remove a pilocytic astrocytoma tumor in her brain.