After a Clinical Trial on Midazolam for Seizures, Emergency Use of the Drug Rises
Michigan Medicine researchers examined how a clinical trial on one drug’s efficacy affected its use in ambulances across the country.
For status epilepticus patients who experience seizures outside of the hospital, treatment administered on an ambulance is an important component of their overall care.
And, according to a new study, this care is improving thanks in part to increased knowledge around — and availability of — midazolam, a benzodiazepine.
"When people experience seizures we frequently call an ambulance, and they're treated with a benzodiazepine if they're still having a seizure when the ambulance arrives," says William Meurer, M.D., associate professor of emergency medicine at Michigan Medicine and a member of the Michigan Center for Integrative Research in Critical Care and the University of Michigan Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation. "There are a few type of benzodiazepines that can be used, one of which is midazolam."
Meurer is the senior author on a new study that investigated if previous research on midazolam's efficacy as a seizure treatment affected whether ambulances nationwide were choosing the drug over other benzodiazepines for seizure patients.
The team focused on a clinical trial, titled RAMPART and published in 2012, in which lead author Robert Silbergleit, M.D., also of Michigan Medicine, and his team demonstrated that midazolam was more effective in treating seizures than other benzodiazepines. Because it is injected, rather than administered through an IV, it is also faster to use, RAMPART found.
"Here, we have a situation where this drug works as a treatment, is faster to administer, is cheaper than others, and it's easier to use because it doesn't have to be refrigerated like some other benzos," Meurer says. "But, we know that the process of clinical trial findings moving into accepted clinical practice can take years and years. We wanted to see, after RAMPART was published, how quickly and how much did a clinical trial change what ambulances were doing across the country."
Meurer adds, "Ambulances are different than a doctor; for example, sometimes they make yearly decisions on what medicines they stock. If a doctor wants to start prescribing a different medication to a seizure patient, they can generally do so right away. With ambulances, there could be administrative delays from the agency."
It's encouraging to see EMS agencies embracing clinical trial results and knowledge gained through these trials.William Meurer, M.D.
The research team used data from the National Emergency Medical Services Information System, a national repository of standardized patient care reports from EMS agencies across the country. They compared data from the two years prior to RAMPART's publication with the two years after its publication, when midazolam was used as the first-line treatment.
The team identified all patient care events, both pediatric and adult, where the patient was treated with benzodiazepines for seizures and presumed convulsive status epilepticus in the pre-hospital setting from Jan. 1, 2010, to Dec. 31, 2014.
They found 156,539 benzodiazepine-treated seizures. Using statistical analysis, the researchers concluded midazolam use increased from 26.1 percent in January 2010 to 61.7 percent in December 2014. In addition, the annual rate of EMS agencies adopting midazolam annually increased from 5.9 percent per year to 8.9 percent per year after the publication of RAMPART.
After adjusting for secular trends, demographic characteristics, EMS encounter characteristics and agency size, the team found the odds of a patient receiving midazolam were 24 percent higher after the RAMPART study's publication.
"We found a substantial increase in the use of midazolam and the rate at which it was adopted after RAMPART," Meurer says. "It's hard to say this can all be attributed to RAMPART. Perhaps people were already learning more about midazolam and its benefits, but it's encouraging to see EMS agencies embracing clinical trial results and knowledge gained through these trials."
The team also performed a secondary analysis for rates of airway interventions and rescue therapy for patients treated with midazolam and noted little change in those values from before and after RAMPART was published.
The future of midazolam
While midazolam is gaining traction in the seizure community, it has already been used for several years for lethal injections — perhaps to the detriment of seizure patients.
"I'm fearful this important drug may suffer the same fate some of its fellow injections, such as sodium thiopental, have seen," Meurer says. "Drug companies aren't making enough money off of midazolam to make it worth the bad press it gets from executions."
Meurer hopes its benefits for patients will outweigh the negative attention, adding,
"I hope people will realize this drug is so much more widely used than sodium thiopental was and is incredibly beneficial to this patient population."
This article is from the Health Lab digital publication.
Get a weekly digest of medical research and innovation, straight to your inbox.