Early result acceptance programs could bring innovative change to medical residency applications

Two medical education experts are leading the charge when it comes to reimagining the path forward for future doctors with ERAPs.

2:33 PM

Author | Jina Sawani

young woman doctor anxious worried side view with hair up white coat
Getty Images

Over the last decade, the number of medical residency applications submitted by hopeful candidates has grown exponentially.

According to the American Association of Medical Colleges, the number of applications submitted by medical students seeking to match into obstetrics and gynecology programs grew to an average of 72 in 2021.

While many may assume that this significant growth is normal due to the highly competitive nature surrounding the residency application process, experts note otherwise.  

"It's startling to see how many fourth-year medical students are overapplying to residency programs. The number of open positions is still the same, but there are multifactorial reasons why the application numbers keep growing," said Helen Kang Morgan, M.D.,  professor of obstetrics and gynecology and learning health sciences at the University of Michigan Medical School. "For example, some students may feel extra pressure to overapply to programs just in case their first or second choices don't work out. And there are very few incentives for them to do anything differently. In addition, students know that the percent of applicants who match into one of their top ranked positions continues to decrease."

Morgan is a co-investigator and program evaluation lead for the Association of Professors of Gynecology and Obstetrics, or APGO, AMA Reimagining Residency Grant, "Right Resident, Right Program, Ready Day One." The grant aims to encourage initiatives like creating a more holistic review process for residency applicants and advocating for an early result acceptance program to help alleviate the excessive number of applications submitted each year. 

The primary-investigator for the grant, Maya Hammoud, M.D., M.B.A., also a professor of obstetrics and gynecology and learning health sciences at U-M Medical School, added that the "costs of these behaviors are quite significant" for medical students and can include financial, educational and emotional stressors.

MORE FROM THE LAB: Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

"Students in their final year of medical school should really be focusing on how they can best thrive during their residency trainings," said Hammoud. "But instead, they're often bogged down by an insurmountable amount of stress associated with the application and interview processes, which are also very expensive."

These notions led the team to further examine if an early result acceptance program, usually referred to as ERAP, would improve the residency match process for OB-GYN applicants. Their findings were recently published in JAMA Network. 

"We know that the excessive amount of residency applications has a twofold effect," said Hammoud. "Not only are the students impacted, but the program directors and their staff are as well. So, we wanted to assess what key stakeholders within the application process thought about an early acceptance program to help revise this process and eliminate stress and inequities associated with the rising number of applications."

The study breakdown

Various stakeholders involved in the OB-GYN residency application process were surveyed electronically regarding their interest in an ERAP from March to April of 2021.

"We primarily focused on OB-GYN residency applicants, as well as members of the AAMC Group on Student Affairs, OB-GYN clerkship directors, residency program managers and program directors," said Morgan. "We really wanted to survey a snapshot of everyone involved in this process. When we were designing the survey itself, we incorporated feedback from OB-GYN educators, administrative leaders, medical students and residents."

To ensure that "match results" did not sway the answers of participants, the team administered the survey before Match Day.  

"The survey clearly defined ERAP as a 'binding early decision process' where students would only apply to a limited number of programs," said Morgan. "The programs could then make a portion of their residency openings available through this process, with matches announced in September, just before the main match is opened."

Using a Likert scale, each survey recipient was asked to indicate their likelihood of participating in an ERAP as a program staffer or recommending the process to one of their peers as an applicant. In addition, the respondents were asked to make a recommendation regarding their thoughts on the appropriate number of open residency positions within their program or the number of applications submitted by candidates, respectively.

"Our results were very telling, in that a majority of the stakeholder respondents said that they would participate in an ERAP, while we also observed increased numbers (in support of ERAPs) among our student respondents," said Morgan. "The survey data also showed that a proposed ERAP would include three applications per candidate and allow programs to open 25% to 50% of their positions to applicants within the first stage of the match."

Hammoud added that these findings are so significant because they will decrease the financial costs incurred by applicants, while alleviating some of their anxiety and allowing them to focus on their futures as aspiring physicians during their last year before entering their residency program.

"The removal of unnecessary applications from competitive candidates would also usher in a more holistic review process for others," she said. "And we are very excited about what the future holds."  

Paper cited: "Perspectives of Stakeholders About an Early Result Acceptance Program to Complement the Residency Match in Obstetrics and Gynecology," JAMA Network. DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.24158

Like Podcasts? Add the Michigan Medicine News Break on iTunes, Google Podcasts or anywhere you listen to podcasts.


More Articles About:

Med-U Medical School Health Care Quality Education Future Think Occupational Health Demographics Hospitals & Centers
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells

Health Lab

Explore thousands of health news & research stories by visiting the Health Lab homepage for more.

Media Contact

University Hospital at U-M Health in the spring with flowering trees in foreground and Survival Flight helicopter visible

Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe

Featured News & Stories

Rachel Upjohn Building groundbreaking ceremony
News Release

How U-M helped bring depression out of the darkness

The history of the founding of the Eisenberg Family Depression Center at the University of Michigan, the nation's first center focused on research, community outreach and stigma reduction in depression and bipolar disorder.
Medicaid magnifying glass
Health Lab

What’s changing in Medicaid and what can you do?

With eligibility rules for people with lower incomes changing in every state, it’s important to stay up to date, seek trustworthy sources and not fall for misinformation
UMich Med Mosaic on blue background with colorful geometric shapes
UMich Med Mosaic

Beyond the White Coat: Disability, Neurodiversity and Advocacy in Medical School

In this episode of UMich Med Mosaic, host Mackenzie Kay sits down with medical students Jill Maudlin, Sarah Renberg and Bella Johnson to discuss their experiences as disabled and neurodivergent trainees at the University of Michigan Medical School. They reflect on the personal journeys that led them to medicine, the challenges and strengths that accompany living with disabilities and chronic health conditions and the importance of representation within the medical profession. The conversation explores how disability shapes their approaches to patient care, advocacy and teamwork, as well as the role of the Medical Students for Disability Health Advocacy (MSDHA) organization in creating community and advancing accessibility initiatives. They also discuss Michigan’s accommodations in medical education, efforts to improve disability-related curriculum content and the importance of building a culture where disabled and neurodivergent students can thrive.
Minding Memory with a microphone and a shadow of a microphone on a blue background
Minding Memory

Antipsychotic Use in Nursing Homes: Balancing Medication Safety, Policy, and Dementia Care

In this episode, Lauren Gerlach and Matt Davis speak with Theresa Shireman, PhD, Director of the Center for Gerontology and Healthcare Research and a Professor of Health Services, Policy and Practice and Epidemiology at the Brown University School of Public Health. Dr. Shireman’s research focuses on pharmaceutical policy, pharmacoepidemiology, health services research, and medication use among vulnerable populations. Dr. Shireman discusses her recent study, "Impact of Federal Antipsychotic Use Policy in Nursing Homes on New Diagnoses for Approved Indications in Dementia Residents," published in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. The study examines whether federal policies designed to reduce antipsychotic use in nursing homes were associated with increases in new diagnoses of conditions, such as schizophrenia, that exclude residents from publicly report antipsychotic quality measures. Using an interrupted time-series design, the researchers examined changes following the 2012 National Partnership to Improve Dementia Care and the 2015 addition of antipsychotic use to the Nursing home Five-Star Quality Rating System. They found that neither policy was associated with an increase in new exclusionary diagnossees, challenging concerns that nursing homes were increasingly assigning these diagnoses to circumvent restrictions on antipsychotic use. The conversation also explores the benefits and risks of antipsychotic medications for people living with dementia, including the potential for serious adverse effects such as sedation, falls, stroke, and increased mortality. Dr. Shireman discusses how public reporting and financial incentives can influence prescribing practices,the limitations of using a single quality measure to evaluate nursing home care, and the importance of balancing medication safety and residents’ individual needs. The discussion highlights the need for shared decision-making among clinicians, nursing home staff, residents, and families, as well as greater investment in staffing, resources, and nonpharmacological approaches to improve quality of life for people living with dementia. The transcript for this episode can be found here.
Well-Being at Michigan Medicine with Dr. Elizabeth Harry
Well-Being at Michigan Medicine

Learning Together: Making Space for Growth at Work

What if well-being starts with how we learn together? On this episode of Well-Being at Michigan Medicine, Elizabeth Harry, M.D., is joined by Rajesh Mangrulkar, M.D., FNAP, Executive Director of U-M’s Center for Interprofessional Practice and Education (IPE), Executive Director of Michigan Medicine RISE (Research. Innovation. Scholarship. Education), and primary care physician of internal medicine whose work focuses on organizational leadership and innovation, and Johnny McGraw, M.A., Marketing & Communications Specialist for both RISE and IPE, about building teams through human connection, psychological safety and learning. They discuss a meeting practice, why leaders shape culture and how investments in collaboration can help health care teams work without asking people to carry everything alone.
Purple shaded illustration of doctor listening to heart of patient on a bed
Health Lab

The AI is listening: Implications of machine generated clinical notes on health care

Michigan Medicine experts argue that use of artificial intelligent scribes during health care visits should be more carefully examined .