How a clinical simulation is helping to diversify careers in medicine

The specialized event for historically marginalized and underrepresented medical students comes with ‘astounding’ results, a published survey finds

5:00 AM

Author | Jina Sawani

woman glasses smiling vr headseat
U-M faculty and underrepresented students engage with one another at last year’s SiMfest. All photos courtesy of Michigan Medicine’s Office for Health Equity and Inclusion

According to the Student National Medical Association, their organization has been “committed to supporting current and future historically marginalized students” since 1964. Their goal is to ultimately address the needs of underserved communities, while increasing the number of underrepresented individuals within the field of medicine. 

“Every year, the SNMA hosts the Annual Medical Education Conference, or AMEC, and since 2017, Michigan Medicine’s Office for Health Equity and Inclusion has organized a simulation festival for the students attending this conference,” said David J. Brown, M.D., who serves as the associate vice president and associate dean for health equity and inclusion at the University of Michigan Medical School.

The Michigan event, coined ‘SiMfest,’ includes interactive clinical stations and several hands-on experiences for AMEC students to partake in. Many departments from the hospital participate, bringing with them simulation equipment to lead prospective students through clinical simulations in their specialty areas.

SEE ALSO: Educational Handover: Helping Medical Students Transition into Residency Programs (michiganmedicine.org)

“Over 40 Michigan Medicine chairs, faculty members, house officers and staff join in on SiMfest, and Michigan is the only school that organizes such an event, which in turn generates a lot of positive impressions about our academic medical center,” said Brown.

Brown says SiMfest provides students with an opportunity to envision themselves working at the medical center alongside faculty members and current house officers, which gives them a sense of the culture at the U-M Medical School.

A mission to improve diversity

The idea of SiMfest came to be after focus groups with several house officers underrepresented in medicine lacked feedback about diversity.

“We asked them [in the focus groups] why they chose to come to Michigan Medicine to continue their training. The unanimous response from each of them was because of the quality of training at Michigan Medicine and they emphasized our outstanding patient care. Response after response seemed to revolve around this theme, but very few mentioned the diversity within our residency training programs,” said Brown.

Brown felt they could organize a hands-on simulation event at SNMA that could demonstrate the school’s commitment to education and dedication to diversity.

Prior to participating, 18% of students reported interest in applying to our institution for the next phase of their medical training. However, nearly 66% of pre-medical students and 63% of medical students reported a strong interest in applying to the U-M Medical School upon participating in our event.”

- Marcia Perry, M.D.

The idea took off, with SiMfest now around since 2017.

Positive, and published, feedback

Brown and a team of colleagues from OHEI surveyed SiMfest participants and volunteers about their experiences with the event from 2017 to 2019. The medical students were asked to anonymously provide information regarding “the value of their clinical experience, area of clinical interest and willingness to apply for training at [the U-M Medical School].”

Their findings were recently published in the Journal of the National Medical Association.

“We were able to gather data from 461 student participants and 83% of those surveyed indicated that they are from a racial category considered historically marginalized,” said Marcia Perry, M.D., who is a co-author of the paper and currently serves as the director of house officer programs within OHEI. “And of those individuals, 91% identified as African American or Black.

demonstrating teaching drilling bone head
Students are offered an opportunity to learn about clinical areas they may be unfamiliar with at SiMfest.

Perry adds that an overwhelming 80% of the student participants rated their experience at SiMfest favorably and said they would recommend it to their peers. In addition, 73% of the pre-medical students and 54% of the medical students surveyed “reported being exposed to a specialty” in which they weren’t previously familiar with.

SEE ALSO: Medical student tackles cystic fibrosis on a global scale | Michigan Medicine

“Prior to participating in SiMfest, a meager 18% of students reported interest in applying to our institution for the next phase of their medical training,” said Perry. “However, nearly 66% of pre-medical students and 63% of medical students reported a strong interest in applying to the U-M Medical School upon participating in our event. This was pretty astounding to see.”

Brown notes that their findings were not exclusive to their student participants, as clinical departmental volunteers were also surveyed about their experiences at SiMfest. 

SEE ALSO: Diversifying medicine (michiganmedicine.org)

“We found that SiMfest inspired many of them – 66% – to pursue other initiatives focused on diversity, equity and inclusion within their own departments,” he said. “This experience broadened the exposure of our chairs and faculty to a large cohort of bright, talented, and diverse future physicians.”

According to Perry, half of the departmental representatives surveyed felt that SiMfest “enhanced awareness and engagement [around] diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives among [Michigan Medicine’s] leadership,” and 72% reported that the event should continue, as they felt it was worth their time and efforts.

“The entirety of SiMfest is so important because its benefits are twofold,” she said. “Not only do students within marginalized communities get profound exposure to a clinical setting from our institution, but many of our own white faculty members also recognize that there are strong students from schools they didn’t even know about prior to participating in this event. This is an opportunity for them to learn more about historically Black colleges, for example, and other organizations involving underrepresented students, as well.”

measuring breathing ultrasound dummy vitals two people at conference closer up
A physician and a student participant interact at SiMfest, a clinical simulation festival. 

SEE ALSO: One Doctor’s Journey to Diversify Medicine (michiganmedicine.org)

Looking ahead, Brown is confident that their work will continue to have a resounding impact on underrepresented students within the field of medicine.

“Because SNMA has the largest amount of underrepresented pre-medical and medical students coming together at a single conference, we’ve really seen the value in our presence there,” said Brown. “We have been fortunate to have a few SiMfest participants match with our residency programs. Our continued strong presence at AMEC shows our true commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion; and Michigan will continue to attract diverse excellence to our medical school and training programs.” 

SEE ALSO: Program Connects Detroit High Schoolers with U-M Med Students (michiganmedicine.org)

Paper cited: “Creating opportunities to engage with prospective historically marginalized trainees with clinical simulation,” Journal of the National Medical Association. DOI: 10.1016/j.jnma.2023.01.005


More Articles About: Med-U Medical School Future Think Education Race Demographics Race and Ethnicity
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of health care news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe
Featured News & Stories blood pressure cuff on mans arm with white coat doctor taking it
Health Lab
Blood pressure high for years? Beware of stroke risk
A study led by Michigan Medicine narrows in on the cumulative effects of years of high systolic blood pressure — the top number on the blood pressure reading and how hard the heart pumps blood to the arteries — finding that a higher average reading during adulthood is linked with a greater risk for the two most common types of stroke.
white coats hanging and one swinging off hanger with purple haze over them and sunshine peeking through
Health Lab
Who feels ready for residency?
Helen Morgan, M.D., of Michigan Medicine, authored a study that surveyed obstetric and gynecology residents to determine who feels prepared for the transition from medical school to residency.
Vitaliy Popov
Medical School News
Improving shared decision-making among interprofessional teams
A new teaching tool, Radar, is helping teams improve their shared decision-making skills in educational and patient settings. Innovator Vitaliy Popov is receiving funding and support through the RISE Innovation Development Program. The project was originally funded through the Center for Interprofessional Education.
two women posing together smiling
Health Lab
The data says we need to talk about physician mental health early
A medical student and surgery faculty member studied the longevity of depression symptoms developed by first-year resident trainees. With their findings now published, they hope to use this data to destigmatize conversations about physician mental health and pave the way for better cultural and institutional support.
Health Lab Podcast in brackets with a background with a dark blue translucent layers over cells
Health Lab Podcast
Addressing health care inequality
An expert on racial and ethnic differences in health care and health outcomes offers recommendations as part of a national committee.
woman sitting at table in stripe shirt stressed seeming white background window
Health Lab
An unequal toll of financial stress
Inflation rates may have cooled off recently, but a poll shows many older adults are experiencing financial stress – especially those who say they’re in fair or poor physical health or mental health