Children often exposed to problematic clickbait during YouTube searches

Study suggests automated video recommendations for young users don’t always filter out violence or other content that’s not age appropriate

11:49 AM

Author | Beata Mostafavi

child on comp screen dark room with teddy bar blonde hair
Getty Images

When a child peruses YouTube, the content recommended to them isn’t always age appropriate, a study suggests.

Researchers mimicked search behaviors of children using popular search terms, such as memes, Minecraft and Fortnite, and captured video thumbnails recommended at the end of each video.

Among the 2,880 thumbnails analyzed, many contained problematic clickbait, such as violence or frightening images, according to the Michigan Medicine led research in JAMA Network Open.

“Children spend a significant amount of time on free video sharing platforms that include user-generated content,” said lead author Jenny Radesky, M.D., developmental behavioral pediatrician at University of Michigan Health C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital.

“It’s important to understand that platforms with billions of hours of content can’t perform human review of everything suggested to children and use algorithms that are imperfect. Parents and children need to be aware of the risks of exposure to inappropriate content and develop strategies to avoid it.”

Some research suggests children eight years and younger spend about 65% of their online time on video sharing sites, many averaging an hour a day, Radesky says.

With hundreds of videos uploaded to such platforms every minute, most content moderation sites rely on automated systems to flag videos that violate policies or depict violent or dangerous content. 

In response, some platforms like YouTube have created made-for-kids labels to identify content appropriate for younger viewers.

But recent research suggests that many young children seek out videos that don’t fall in the “child-friendly” categories, searching for influencers, video games or funny videos.

Among thumbnails yielded in searches, more than half were identified as including “shocking, dramatic or outrageous” messaging, the study suggests. 

It’s important to understand that platforms with billions of hours of content can’t perform human review of everything suggested to children and use algorithms that are imperfect.”  Jenny Radesky, M.D.

A little less than a third included violence, peril and pranks while 29% included “creepy, bizarre and disturbing” imagery. 

Researchers flagged other content suggestions for “visual loudness,” or using attention capturing designs, as well as manufactured drama and intrigue and depictions of far-fetched luxury items, such as cars, jewelry and houses. 

A smaller percentage of automated suggestions included gender stereotypes.

“These findings contribute to growing research on how digital designs aim to capture and keep users’ attention,” Radesky said. 

“We need more research on children’s interactions with these platforms to guide better polices that protect them from negative media experiences.”

Additional authors include Enrica Bridgewater, B.S.; Shira Black; August O’Neil; Yilin Sun; Alexandria Schaller, B.A.; Heidi Weeks, Ph.D. and Scott Campbell, Ph.D., all of U-M.

Study cited: “Algorithmic Content Recommendations on a Video-sharing platform used by children,” JAMA Network Open. DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.13855

Sign up for the Health Lab Podcast: Add us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get you listen to your favorite shows.


More Articles About:

Children's Health C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital Preventative health and wellness Wellness and Prevention Developmental Milestones Community Health Growth and Development
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells

Health Lab

Explore thousands of health news & research stories by visiting the Health Lab homepage for more.

Media Contact

University Hospital at U-M Health in the spring with flowering trees in foreground and Survival Flight helicopter visible

Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

In This Story

Jenny Radesky

Jenny Radesky, MD

Associate Professor

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe

Featured News & Stories

An adult gently rests their hands on a baby who is sleeping in a NICU isolette.
Philanthropy News

A gift for Michigan’s most vulnerable babies

A gift from the Carls Foundation is helping ensure specialized care for babies and families in the Brandon NICU and Reese Partlow PCTU at C.S. Mott Children's Hospital.
Woman in pink shirt paints a float character with bright blue paint.
Health Lab

After 13 years of IV nutrition, teen finds freedom to just be a kid

Born with a rare intestinal condition called gastroschisis, Mackenzie spent much of her childhood at the hospital. Today, the 15-year-old is making honor roll and looking ahead to a future in nursing.
Man sits in a medical exam room looking at caregiver whose back is to camera and looks toward a computer screen.
Health Lab

Updated prostate cancer screening guidelines emphasize benefits of early detection

New guidelines for prostate cancer screening focus on early detection and individual risk.
Close up of woman's mouth as cheek swab is performed, with Q tip held in a green medical gloved hand.
Health Lab

Are you at risk of a genetic disease? Guidelines for testing should be updated, experts say

Genetic counselor calls for updated guidelines on testing for diseases like Huntington's and Alzheimer's diseases.
Child in blue shirt smiles on the green grass of a football field
Health Lab

FDA approved drug slows type 1 diabetes progression in 5-year-old patient

After a family history of type 1 diabetes led to early screening through TrialNet, 5-year-old Trevor became Michigan's youngest patient to receive delay-inducing drug TZIELD.
A group of costumed med students sing together outside an Ann Arbor storefront.
Philanthropy News

Galens Tag Days celebrates 100 years of helping kids

University of Michigan Medical Students are celebrating the 100th annual Galens Tag Days fundraiser for Washtenaw County children’s organizations.